Never give a recorded statement to the at-fault driver’s insurance company without an attorney present. In Florida, you are not legally obligated to do so, and adjusters will use your recorded words to minimize your injuries or shift blame onto you to reduce their financial liability.
These recorded statements are designed to help the insurance company to gather information to use against you. They typically ask very open-ended questions like “have you ever had back pain before?”, or “have you seen a doctor for neck pain in the last 10 years?”
These are not questions that are designed to help you and to assist you as you recover from an accident that their insured caused. They are designed to build a claim where they can later say that your injuries were a pre-existing condition and you’re only entitled to partial recovery. Insurance adjusters know that people are shaken up after an accident and utilize these first day to try to trap them into giving a statement by leaving them to believe they have no choice. I would advise anyone who is considering hiring a lawyer to speak with one as soon as possible before you go on record with any insurance company, including your own.
The Trap of the “Friendly” Adjuster Call
I have seen this exact scenario play out for thirty years in Southwest Florida. You get rear-ended in heavy traffic on US-41 here in Bonita Springs. A day later, a polite adjuster calls, asking to hear your side of the story so they can “process the claim faster” and get your vehicle fixed. It sounds helpful, but it is a trap designed to gather evidence against you.
It is very confusing to know who is on your side or there to help you after an accident. It is in the adjusters playbook to make you feel safe and act like they’re there to help you. The truth is, the adjuster works for the insurance company whose job is to pay you the least amount possible to sell your claim. They will use whatever tactics they can to be able to minimize your payout and use your statement against you.
Following the 2023 Florida tort reform, comparative negligence rules are stricter than ever. If the defense can get you to say something on tape that implies you were even partially distracted, they can severely reduce your compensation. They ask leading questions about your speed, what you were looking at, or how your body feels. If you say, “I’m just a little sore,” they will use that recording to deny your claim when you discover three days later that you have a herniated disc.
Consider how this plays out in real life:
A Bonita Springs driver was T-boned at an intersection and politely told the other driver’s adjuster they “felt fine” hours after the crash. Weeks later, they required surgery for a torn rotator cuff. Our firm stepped in, blocked the insurer’s attempt to use the initial statement to deny the claim, and recovered $300,000 for the client.
We had to fight harder to secure that compensation because the insurance company tried to weaponize a casual conversation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I have to talk to my own insurance company?
Yes. Your auto policy requires you to cooperate with your own insurer. However, you should have our office handle that communication to protect your PIP benefits and ensure your statement is accurate and legally sound.
What if the adjuster says they can’t pay my property damage without a statement?
They are testing you. Florida law does not require a recorded statement just to authorize repairs for your bumper. Do not let them bully you into giving up your rights in exchange for a rental car or auto repairs.
Can they use my statement against me in court?
Absolutely. A recorded statement is admissible evidence. If we need to take your case to trial in Lee County or Collier County courts, defense attorneys will play that recording to attack your credibility if your symptoms worsened after the phone call.
Let Our Firm Handle the Insurance Adjusters
You should be focusing on recovering from your injuries, not stressing over trick questions from an insurance adjuster. Our office steps in and takes over all communication with the insurance companies from day one so they can no longer contact you directly.
If you or a family member have been injured in a crash in Bonita Springs, Fort Myers, or Naples, reach out to us before you talk to the other driver’s insurance company.
Call Pittman Law Firm at 239-992-8259 for a free consultation.
David B. Pittman, Esq. is the founder of Pittman Law Firm, P.L., bringing over 30 years of dedicated personal injury practice to Southwest Florida. A graduate of The Citadel and the University of South Carolina School of Law, David holds an AV-Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell and is a member of the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum. He also brings a unique, practical perspective to property and premises liability cases as a 25-year licensed Florida Real Estate Broker. His trial-ready approach has secured major recoveries for clients throughout Lee and Collier counties.
Legal Disclaimer: The information provided on this website does not, and is not intended to, constitute legal advice. All content is for general informational purposes only. Use of, and access to, this website or any of the links or resources contained within the site do not create an attorney-client relationship between the reader, user, or browser and the authors or contributors.