Holding Dog Owners Strictly Liable for Animal Attacks in Southwest Florida
An unprovoked dog attack is a violent event that frequently leaves victims with severe puncture wounds, nerve damage, and permanent facial scarring. Whether you were walking your own pet through a Bonita Springs neighborhood, visiting a friend’s home, or attacked at a local park, the physical and emotional recovery is exhausting.
You should not be forced to bear the financial burden of someone else’s failure to secure their animal. At Pittman Law Firm, P.L., we leverage Florida’s strict liability dog bite statutes to hold negligent owners and their insurance companies fully accountable.
Combining Attorney David Pittman’s 30 years of Southwest Florida trial experience with Kristin Pittman’s insider knowledge as an active Licensed Florida Insurance Adjuster, we cut through the red tape, defeat insurance company stall tactics, and secure maximum compensation for your trauma.
Bonita Springs Personal Injury Lawyers Reviews
Florida is a “Strict Liability” State (No “Free Bite” Rule)
In many states, a dog owner is only financially responsible for an attack if their dog has a documented history of aggression. Florida law does not protect negligent owners this way.
Under Fla. Stat. § 767.04, Florida is a strict liability state. This means a dog owner is legally and financially responsible for any injuries their dog causes the very first time it bites someone. You do not have to prove the owner was blatantly reckless. You only have to prove that their dog bit you and that you were either in a public place or lawfully on private property, such as a guest in a home, when the attack occurred.
Furthermore, if the owner was violating local leash laws, such as the Lee County Animal Control Ordinance requiring dogs to be leashed and controlled when off the owner’s property, we use this violation as negligence per se to aggressively strengthen your claim.
How We Block Victim-Blaming Tactics
Because dog bites frequently result in high-value settlements, insurance adjusters will actively look for statutory loopholes to deny your claim. As an active Licensed Florida Insurance Adjuster, Kristin Pittman knows exactly how carriers try to twist Florida law to avoid paying.
The “Provocation” Defense
Insurance companies will attempt to use Florida’s comparative negligence statute to claim you provoked the dog, thereby reducing your compensation. We secure witness statements and expert testimony to prove the attack was unprovoked and defeat this victim-blaming tactic.
The “Bad Dog” Sign Exception
Under Florida law, an owner can sometimes avoid strict liability if they displayed an easily readable “Bad Dog” sign on their property. However, this exception is legally void if the victim is a child under the age of six, or if the dog owner’s own negligence, such as leaving a gate wide open, directly caused the attack.
Where Does the Settlement Money Come From?
One of the biggest concerns victims have, especially if the dog belongs to a neighbor, friend, or family member, is how the settlement will be paid. You are rarely suing the individual directly out of pocket. You are pursuing a claim against their insurance company.
Homeowner’s Insurance Claims
Most dog bite settlements are paid directly out of the dog owner’s homeowner’s or renter’s liability policy. We immediately locate the policy, identify the coverage limits, and file the claim.
Overcoming Breed Exclusions
Many insurance companies write breed exclusions into their policies, attempting to deny coverage if the attack involved a Pit Bull, Rottweiler, or German Shepherd. We heavily scrutinize the policy language to defeat these exclusions and force the carrier to pay.
Premises Liability for Landlords
If a landlord or property manager knew a legally classified dangerous dog under Fla. Stat. § 767.12 was living in their Bonita Springs apartment complex and failed to remove the hazard, we can frequently pursue the commercial property’s insurance policy for your damages.
Crucial Steps to Take After an Animal Attack
Dog bite injuries carry an extremely high risk of severe infection. Taking immediate action protects both your health and your legal claim.
1. Seek Emergency Medical Care
Do not wait. Puncture wounds trap bacteria deep inside the tissue. Go immediately to the Lee Health emergency room, NCH Bonita, or a local urgent care. Prompt medical records are essential to prove the severity of the attack to the insurance company.
2. Report the Attack to Animal Control
Contact Lee County Domestic Animal Services immediately. They will investigate the animal’s vaccination history to determine your rabies risk. An official investigation also creates a government record of the incident and triggers the statutory process to determine if the animal must be legally classified as a dangerous dog.
3. Identify the Owner and Witnesses
Get the name and address of the dog’s owner. If there were witnesses at the Bonita Beach Dog Park or in your neighborhood, ask for their contact information before they leave the scene.
4. Photograph Your Injuries
Take clear photos of your wounds before they are bandaged, your torn clothing, and the exact location where the attack occurred.
No Fees Unless We Win • Free Case Evaluation
Don’t Let Insurance Companies Undervalue Your Case
Insurance companies look for ways to reduce payouts. Pittman Law Firm stands up for you and fights to recover the full compensation you deserve.
Advocating for Victims of Severe Trauma
A dog’s jaws can exert hundreds of pounds of pressure per square inch, causing catastrophic crushing and tearing damage. Children are particularly vulnerable to dog bites because their height puts their face and neck directly in the strike zone.
We aggressively document your physical injuries and the long-term psychological impact of the attack to demand full compensation for:
Permanent Facial Scarring and Disfigurement
Often requiring future plastic or reconstructive surgery.
Nerve Damage and Loss of Motor Function
Common in the hands and arms when victims attempt to defend themselves.
Deep Puncture Wounds, Tendon Damage, and Muscle Tearing
Severe Infections
Including MRSA, staph infections, Pasteurella, and rabies exposure.
Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)
Including severe anxiety around animals and lasting emotional trauma.
Why Choose Pittman Law Firm, P.L.?
Insurance adjusters will use every legal maneuver available to delay your claim or reduce your financial payout.
We block these defense tactics. With 30 years of personal injury trial experience in Southwest Florida and an in-house Licensed Florida Insurance Adjuster, we build airtight cases and negotiate from a position of absolute strength.
Our Zero-Fee Guarantee
We operate strictly on a contingency fee basis. We advance all the money required to investigate the attack, acquire medical records, and fight the insurance companies. You pay zero upfront costs, zero hourly fees, and you owe us absolutely nothing unless we successfully recover a financial settlement or jury verdict in your favor.
Frequently Asked Questions About Florida Dog Bite Lawsuits
I was bitten by a friend’s dog. Will suing them ruin them financially?
No. In the vast majority of cases, we do not seek money from your friend’s personal bank account. We file the claim against their homeowner’s or renter’s insurance liability policy. That is exactly what they pay their insurance premiums for, to cover incidents like this.
Do I have to prove the dog was legally classified as a dangerous dog before the attack?
No. Under Florida’s strict liability statute, you do not need to prove the dog had a prior bite history or was previously investigated by Lee County Animal Control. The owner is strictly liable for the very first bite.
How long do I have to file a lawsuit for a dog bite in Florida?
Under Fla. Stat. § 95.11(4)(a), Florida recently shortened the statute of limitations for negligence and personal injury cases. You now have exactly two years from the date of the animal attack to file a lawsuit. If you miss this strict deadline, your claim will be permanently barred by the court.